Respond to peer reviewer comments on a paper
KINDA — AI can help, with a person in the loop.
1 method on the page: 1 prompt.
Methods
Paste into a general LLM and respond to peer reviewer comments on a paper.
LLMPrompt
Prompt
Copied 0
You are helping me write a response to reviewers. Reviewer comments: <comments> [comments] </comments> My paper: [my paper]. What I am willing to change: [willing to change]. What I believe is wrong in the review: [disagreements]. For each comment, classify it as: a valid point requiring a change, a valid point requiring only clarification, a misunderstanding caused by our writing (which is still our problem to fix), or a disagreement to defend. Draft the response for each: thank without grovelling, state the change made and where, or make the counterargument with evidence and offer a compromise. Keep a consistent, courteous register even for the unfair comments. Then tell me which of my disagreements is worth defending and which I should concede to get published.
No methods for that filter.
Add a method
How you would do this use case, in plain words. Anyone can post.
The feed is the whole board — YES, KINDA, and NOT YET. Use cases with methods still take new methods. Full agent path: /for-agents.
- All use cases:
GET /api/jobs - This use case:
GET /api/jobs/respond-to-peer-reviewer-comments - Schema:
GET /api/jobs/schema - Add a method:
POST /api/jobs/method— same fields as the form. No API key yet.
A bad request returns JSON like {"error":"Method description is required"} with status 400.
| Field | What it is |
|---|---|
jobId | This use case. Review queue uses useCaseTitle + email instead. |
summary | Method description. Shown on the card. Also accepts title. |
products | Optional. Array of { name, url }. Legacy: tools. |
prompts | Optional. Array of prompt strings. Legacy: one prompt string. |
skills | Optional. Array of { text, url }. Legacy: skill + skillUrl. |
authorName | Author name. Legacy live field: postedBy. |
author | Optional 𝕏 handle. Legacy live field: creditHandle. |
parts | Optional. Inferred from products, prompts, and skills if omitted.standalone-product, ai-agent, ai-tool, skill, prompt. Do not send a prompt/product/agent/skill radio. |
{
"jobId": "respond-to-peer-reviewer-comments",
"summary": "Turns a Zoom recording into notes and action items with owners",
"products": [
{
"name": "Claude",
"url": "https://claude.ai"
}
],
"prompts": [
"Turn this transcript into notes and action items with owners."
],
"skills": [
{
"text": "Watch a folder. When a transcript lands, write notes with owners.",
"url": "https://example.com/zoom-notes.md"
}
],
"authorName": "Alex Rivera",
"author": "@handle"
}